Churches try to
keep human touch with new media
By Mark A. Kellner
(4/11/04)
A growing number
of 21st-century churches are moving toward technologically driven
worship services. Digital cameras capture worship throughout
the sanctuary; PowerPoint presentations deliver the words to
songs, sermon points and even Scripture passages.
Some see technology
as a means of ministering more effectively in church services;
others see it as a distraction.
One thing is clear:
Technology has changed and will continue to change the way American
Christians worship.
According to media
ministers at several larger Assemblies of God churches, “high-tech”
worship systems are enabling newcomers, as well as longtime
attendees, to experience personal worship even when the sanctuary
seats 3,000 people and is packed to the rafters.
Brian Steckman, lighting
director at Phoenix First Assembly in Arizona, says multimedia
efforts help orient first-time visitors to the order of the
service. “We try to gear what happens on the big screen
to show people how to become participators in worship as opposed
to spectators of worship,” he says.
Siobhan Klos, production
director at Phoenix First Assembly, agrees.
“When people
are unchurched and don’t know the words to a song, if
they see words on a screen they’re more likely to sing
along,” Klos says. “If they don’t know the
words, they won’t join in. It creates an atmosphere to
help worship.”
“The goal of
any church today is to be relevant to the community and the
people who are walking in the doors,” says Mark Hermann,
media and technologies director at Capital Christian Center
in Sacramento, Calif. “We are so attuned to walking in
and watching TV. While some might classify [our use of technology]
as entertainment, we call it being relevant to the people we
are trying to reach.”
Of course, anything
can be used to excess, and already warnings are being sounded
about the deployment of technology in sanctuaries.
In his new book,
High-Tech Worship? Using Presentation Technologies Wisely,
Christian author and media expert Quentin Schultze takes aim
at the PowerPointing of America’s churches. Schultze says
church leaders must realize that these technologies are not
neutral when placed in the sanctuary.
“We have to
put them in the context of worship, rather than allow them to
distort worship,” says Schultze, who lives in Grand Rapids,
Mich. “Technological distortion of worship is transforming
it into either entertainment or teaching as is found in a university
or business setting.”
Schultze notes that
the body of Christ is growing fastest in Africa and Latin America,
where technology is rarely incorporated into worship. “In
the United States we are the most tech-optimistic people in
the world,” Schultze says. “We see tech as the solution
for problems in education, politics, medicine and now religion.”
At the same time,
however, the grafting of high-tech onto the high touch of traditional
worship is producing some positive results, according to Brian
Fuller, who owns Full Circle Media in Raleigh, N.C. Fuller believes
that using technology can draw more members of the church into
participating in worship, even if only in the background.
“Ten years
ago, there was a sense in which the people in the pews considered
themselves to be the audience,” Fuller says. “The
congregation was preached at or to. They were occasionally enlisted
in singing, but they were not performing. Now, even in a church
of 300 people, a media-savvy service involves a lot more people.”
Fuller adds that
the 14-year-olds who know how to make PowerPoint presentations
are connecting with 80-year-olds who have visual materials that
can be used for those slides: “That’s a kind of
intergenerational collaboration of worship we haven’t
seen for a long time. I’m wholly excited.”
Greg Slape, director
of communications technologies at James River Assembly in Ozark,
Mo., is an enthusiastic user of technology, but advises there
must be balance.
“It should
be used to make the experience easier,” says Slape. “If
that’s a case of putting the Scripture on the screen so
somebody could actually take notes, then fine. All we’re
doing is making it possible to take notes more accurately.”
Sharon Lister, a
member of James River Assembly for 12 years, has severe nerve
deafness and reads lips. She is grateful that technology has
aided her in understanding preaching and worship and believes
that technological advances encourage more people with a hearing
loss to attend church.
“Music, especially
fast-tempo music, is hard to follow, so I appreciate the words
on the screen,” Lister says. “Also, when the choir
or soloist sings, I can enjoy the music along with the words.”